COPA page Banner.

                               

CALL (812) 333-8888 FOR MORE INFORMATION OR E-MAIL info@copa.org


                             

Library: Rulings: Consent Decree

                               
 

United States District Court

Southern District of Indiana
Indianapolis Division

Return to Part 2.

VI. SOLID WASTE SUPPLIED BY THE CITY AND COUNTY

23. The City and County each have determined that landfilling of solid waste represents a less desirable environmental

and public health alternative to high temperature incineration.

The City and County enter into this Consent Decree separately,

independent of the obligations and the rights of the other.

24. Recognizing the public health need for Westinghouse

to dispose of existing areas of PCB contamination and the need

for the City and County each to dispose properly of solid waste,

the City and County, with the authorization and approval of the





State, have entered separately into this Consent Decree to

dispose of solid waste generated within their respective bound-

aries primarily through incineration and to provide an adequate

fuel supply for PCB incineration.

25. To effectuate this Consent Decree and under the

authority of the State, and pursuant to Indiana Code 36-9-30-5,

the City and County shall each through appropriate ordinances,

regulations and all other necessary actions, direct that all

solid waste generated in the City and County, respectively, that I

capable of incineration shall be delivered to the incinerator

constructed pursuant to Section XXII. In addition, the City and

County shall each bear the responsibility to adopt policies and

regulations to ensure implementation of Sections V, VI and VII of

this Consent Decree.

26. Commencing no later than thirty days after issuance

of the final operating permit required for the incineration of

solid waste at the Westinghouse incinerator facility, the City

and County shall each deliver and Westinghouse shall accept,

incinerate and/or dispose of solid waste as provided in paragraph:

27, 28, 29 and 30. However, the City and County have no obliga-

tion to deliver a minimum quantity of solid waste.

27. The City and County shall each cause to be delivered

all solid waste generated in the City and County, respectively, that

is capable of incineration except:

(a) car bodies;

(b) white goods including refrigerators, stoves,







freezers, water heaters and similar noncombustible domestic

appliances; and

(c) other metal goods of equivalent size.

The County shall maintain an ancillary landfill for disposal of

nonhazardous waste inappropriate for incineration and for white

goods, as provided for in paragraph 31 below. In the event the

City or County inadvertently delivers materials described in sub-

paragraphs (a-c) above to the incinerator site, the City or

County, as the case may be, shall pick up and dispose of such

materials at its expense. Westinghouse is free to return to the

generator, in accordance with all applicable statutes and regula-

tions and at the generator's expense, any specific waste material

contained in the solid waste which Westinghouse identifies as

hazardous under state or federal law.

28. Westinghouse shall, at its sole cost and expense,

sort all solid waste it accepts pursuant to paragraph 26 above,

and shall determine whether such solid waste is appropriate for

incineration.

29. Westinghouse shall utilize all appropriate solid

waste as fuel for the incineration of PCBs, materials contaminated with PCBs and associated hazardous substances in the Westinghouse incinerator facility.

30. Except as provided in paragraph 27, any solid waste

that meets the requirements of paragraph 25 and is subsequently

determined by Westinghouse not to be appropriate for incineration

shall be properly transported and disposed of or recycled by





Westinghouse, at its sole cost and expense, in accordance with

all applicable laws and regulations and requirements of the City

and County.

31. Recognizing that there will be a period of time

before the incinerator can be constructed, that there may be non-

hazardous solid waste that is not suitable for incineration, and

that there will be minimum periods pursuant to paragraph 12 when

the incinerator is not available because of maintenance needs,

the County shall develop and operate, prior to commencement of

operation of the incinerator, ancillary licensed solid waste

landfill facilities to dispose of nonhazardous solid waste as

approved by the State. These ancillary facilities will be

operated solely to dispose of nonhazardous solid waste. The site

for the new landfill facilities may include, but shall not be

limited to, expansion of the existing Anderson Road Landfill or

any other suitable area within the County. The County shall take

all steps necessary, including exercise of eminent domain, to

acquire and develop the site for new landfill facilities.

32. Recognizing that the solid waste of the City and

County provides a valuable fuel supply for the purpose of

destroying PCBs, and at the same time, that incineration provides

a valuable, environmentally sound disposal service for the solid

waste of the City and County, Westinghouse shall receive a tipping fee from the City and County which shall consist of the following:

(a) For each ton of solid waste that is accepted

at the incinerator site, a fee established by Westinghouse which shall be no more than the tipping fee charged by the County for

disposal at its licensed solid waste disposal facilities. The

tipping fee charged by the County at its facilities shall reflect

recovery of capital and operating costs and shall be reviewed

annually. The current tipping fee charged by the County for

disposal at its licensed solid waste disposal facilities is

seven dollars per ton plus a one dollar entry fee.

(b) For each ton of solid waste that is disposed

of by incineration, an additional charge of fifty cents per ton,

for Westinghouse to produce an ash which meets the requirements

for nonhazardous ash established by the EPA under RCRA and any

additional requirements to render the ash nonhazardous estab-

lished by the City pursuant to paragraphs 7 and 39(c).

33. Westinghouse agrees to pay reasonable user charges

for the administration of activities under this Section and

Sections V and VII by the County or City. The user charges shall

be established by the City or County, as the case may be, only

after providing notice to Westinghouse and an opportunity to be

heard.

34. The local approval functions under this Consent

Decree, including those set forth in paragraphs 7 and 39(c),

shall be performed by the City as provided in paragraph 136.

The City shall provide administrative and technical coordination

and support, to the extent necessary, for City and County perfor-

mance under Sections V, VI and VII of this Consent Decree.





VII

ASH DISPOSAL

35. Subject to the written approval of the United

States and State, and at Westinghouse's option, the City shall

make available to Westinghouse for disposal of nonhazardous ash

from the incinerator the City's licensed sludge drying beds and

landfill at its Dillman Road Treatment Facility up to the present

capacity of said Facility. The City and Westinghouse may reach a

mutual written agreement on expansion of the sludge drying beds

and landfill at the Dillman Road Treatment Facility subject to

state and federal approval. If Westinghouse uses the sludge

drying beds and landfill, Westinghouse shall pay the City all

operating and administrative costs associated with permitting and

operating ash disposal activities at those sites. In any event,

Westinghouse shall incinerate at no cost to the City all of the

sludge generated by the Dillman Road Treatment Facility for as

long as Westinghouse operates the incinerator under this Consent

Decree. In addition, Westinghouse shall, at its own cost and

expense, incinerate all of the sludge which had been deposited in

the licensed sludge disposal site prior to commencement of incin-

eration.

36. In the event that Westinghouse does not use the

sludge drying beds and landfill at the Dillman Road Treatment

Facility for disposal of nonhazardous ash from the incinerator

and in accordance with all applicable statutes and regulations,







the City and/or County, as the case may be, shall provide

Westinghouse, at Westinghouse's option, with a licensed solid

waste disposal facility in Monroe County for disposal of non-

hazardous incinerator ash.

37. Westinghouse shall pay the City and/or County,

as the case may be, the full capital, operating, and admin-

istrative costs associated with licensing, constructing and

operating the facility referenced in paragraph 36.

38. Notwithstanding paragraphs 35 and 36, Westinghouse

has the option, at its expense, to construct and operate a

licensed solid waste disposal facility in Monroe County for

disposal of nonhazardous incinerator ash generated by the

incinerator. Westinghouse shall exercise its option in a timely

fashion. In such event, the provisions of paragraphs 36 and 37

shall not apply.

39. Westinghouse may dispose of nonhazardous incinerator

ash from the incinerator pursuant to paragraphs 35, 36 and 38

provided said ash meets the following requirements:

(a) the ash is tested and determined to be non-

hazardous as determined by federal and state requirements for

classifying nonhazardous waste;

(b) the concentration of PCBs in the ash is less

than one part per million ("ppm"); and

(c) the ash meets any additional requirements

imposed by the City as part of the City's review of Westing-

house's technical plans for ash disposal in accordance with

paragraph 7 above.







40. The failure of the City and/or County to provide

Westinghouse with a nonhazardous ash disposal facility pursuant

to this Section shall not relieve Westinghouse of its obligation

to dispose of the ash generated by the incinerator in accordance

with all applicable requirements of local, federal and state

laws and regulations.

41. In the event that any of the incinerator ash cannot

be rendered nonhazardous by Westinghouse, Westinghouse shall not

dispose of such ash in the facilities provided by the City and

County pursuant to paragraphs 35 and 36 above. Westinghouse

shall, at its sole cost and expense, properly dispose of such

hazardous ash in any other facility that is licensed by state

and federal authorities to accept such wastes. Such hazardous

ash shall not be disposed of on the incinerator site.

Continue to Part 4.

 
                               
                               

| The Cast | The Tragedy | The Comedy | The Ending | News | Library | Seating Plan | Top | Home |
                               

CALL (812) 333-8888 FOR MORE INFORMATION OR E-MAIL info@copa.org

                               

The Coaltion Opposed to PCB Ash in Monroe County, Inc. is a nonprofit organization.
205 N. College Ave. - Ste. 713 - P.O. Box 665 - Bloomington, IN 47402-0665 USA
Voice:
+1.812.333.8888 - Fax: +1.812.332.8511 - BBS: +1.812.333.8822

For more info, e-mail info@copa.org. Please send site input to webmaster@copa.org.
Copyright © 1990-98 COPA, Inc. All rights reserved. See legal page for terms
of use and disclaimers. All trademarks belong to their respective owners.
Subscribe to the COPA Mailing List and stay informed on PCBs.